Sketching Glass Apples

[Psaumure]

Tonight I try my hand at sketching some glass apples. I used named colors. it's all vector. Smoothened a little different. I did one with and one without transparencies. Which one do you like?

Paul

[joscari]

Hi,
Very, very good drawings! I like both but if I have to choose one, I prefer the one without transparencies.
Sven-Ingvar

[gwpriester]

Do I have to pick one? They both are very tasty.

[ss-kalm]

I prefer the one without transparencies. But they are both excellent.

[gray]

I like the glass apples, Paul. I prefer the second one as well.

[Psaumure]

Thank you everyone for your comments. I'm still not sure which one I like. I do like the green and yellow apples. The red one looks flat. I'm not sure why. I reworked the red apple. I think it looks a little better.

Paul

[wizard509]

I like them Paul. Of the two I prefer the second on the right. There is something about the green one that bothers me though. It;s like a white rectangle that does not belong I see it showing upper left and overlapping part of the dark outline. I see it on both images.