Originally Posted by
Bob Hahn
Interesting how this thread started and the path it took.
The "company" didn't come to this site asking for designs. The one doing the work (Andy) posted, wondering for any "inspiration." This could of came in the form of written words - how to approach it - guidance, common mistakes to stay away from. Never implying others to supply finished logo designs. Andy may do it for free, he may later be compensated, who knows? - that's his choice.
This forum is visited by many amateur designers and hobbyists. They won't make their designs the same as how a professional designer would and you don't have to be a professional to design, draw or post.
Big Frank, although you later did provide some good inspiration and guidance, I think you were a bit harsh on the posts which were (as I see it) done for fun.
No company posted on this site asking for a free logo. All Andy asked was for inspiration.
Perhaps some of the designs weren't up to par with a professional, but then again, you get what you pay for.