Which skin do you prefer?

[The Alien]

PixelDust, then it's not just me. Too bad, since I was looking for a skin that has very distinctive icons for read vs unread threads/boards.
I find the current icons too washed out and not clear enough.

[wizard509]

Thank you Steve,
That was a big help.
While I liked different parts of various ones, but not any one in its entirety, I did finally make a decision based solely on what I liked visually.

[alexbozhenov]

Default rules.

[AntonyF]

There will probably be a bit of customisation, whatever theme wins. For example at one point I had the TG icon to indicate new/notnew threads. Not sure where that went... may even be my fault. But I want to bring that back. There may be some colour tweaks.

So go for the design that overall you feel is best, even if you have a few caveats.

[Soquili]

Antony wasn't the TG icon tweak for new/notnew on the old InfoPop forums?

[The Alien]

There will probably be a bit of customisation, whatever theme wins.

That's good to hear because it nails the problem for me. I don't care a lot about the overall theme as long as there's enough distinction between elements on the page that improves readability and navigating.

[AntonyF]

Antony wasn't the TG icon tweak for new/notnew on the old InfoPop forums?

Yeah, I wonder if I didn't transfer it from Infopop to vBulletin. To be honest it's so long ago I forget, and am not sure why I wouldn't have done that. Other than maybe one of those jobs "to do" and never did.

[Big Frank]

After all these years isn't it time for a new TG icon? Sounds like a theme for a Xara Challenge to me

[AntonyF]

Could do. Although it was quite hard choosing a favourite last time!

[Big Frank]

Let the Xara management choose or create a poll and let the members choose!